Wednesday, March 17, 2010

Penerangan terhadap Kitab Fadha'il Amal

Soalan : Mengapa Kitab Fadhail Amal mengandungi hadis dhaif dan maudhu'?

Jawapan 1 : Penerangan dari Mufti Mahmud Hassan Gangohi (rahimahullah), Mufti Besar Darul Ulum Deoband dalam fatwa beliau pada 24/3/1395 AH:

"Kemungkinan besar tidak ada hadith yang disepakati oleh semua ulama' sebagai maudhu'. Bagaimana pun terdapat hadith yang dianggap dha'if atau lemah malah dilabel sebagai palsu oleh sebahagian ulama'. Pengarang kitab Fadha'il Amal yang mulia (Maulana Zakariyya rah.) sendiri telah menyentuh tentang perkara ini. Kitab 'Tadribur Rawi' menerangkan bahawa adalah dibolehkan menggunakan hadith dho'if berkaitan dengan fadhilat atau kelebihan-kelebihan amal. Jika sebaliknya, apa yang kamu akan perkatakan tentang Ibn Majah (rah.) apabila Ibn Jauzi (rah.) mengatakan bahawa kebanyakan daripada hadith-hadith yang diriwayatkan oleh beliau sebagai maudhu'? Ibn Majah adalah sebahagian dari silibus madrasah malah salah satu dari 6 kitab sahih. Ibn Majah (rah.) tidak menyebut pun hadith-hadith tersebut sebagai maudhu'. Malah kitab beliau digunakan tanpa sebarang bantahan.

Pengarang kitab Fadha'il Amal sangat berhati-hati. Beliau telah menerangkan tentang hadith-hadith yang sesetengah ulama' mengatakan sebagai maudhu'. Jika sekiranya semua ulama bersepakat bahawa hadith-hadith tersebut adalah maudhu', beliau sekali-kali tidak akan meriwayatkannya."


  1. Basic Islamic Solution: Shane Nuzul ( the background stories of the Wahi )
    “'Shan' means position, incident, context ect. And 'Nuzul' means revelation. Ayats and Suras of the Holy Quran were revealed in the contest of certain incidents ...”
    How weired the statement is –Was Allah dependant on some incidence to occure and then to give guidline to human.
    Was Quran given in one piece at a time?
    Listen to Know the details of How the Writers of “Shane Nuzul” have made a joke of our Prophet Hajarat Mohamed ( SAW).
    Surah 80 He Frowned & Surah Noor
    Show me what sect the Hajarat Mohamed ( SAW) belonged to a Sunni, Wahabi, Hanafi?
    The same people have written Meraj event who had written Shane Nuzul (How the Writers of “Shane Nuzul” have made a joke of our Prophet Hajarat Mohamed ( SAW).
    All these happened just after 200 years after Hijri
    Shane Nuzul Likhne Walo ne Hajrat Mohamed SAW Ko kisi Traha Majak Bana diya He _-Suniye સુનિયે
    App hi Batayiye Our Beloved Prophet Hajrat Mohamed SAW Sunni the, Wahabi the, Hanafi the?
    શાને નુઝુલ લખવા વાળાઓએ હજરત મોહમેદ સ.અ.વ. ની કેવી રીતે મઝાક બનાવી તે સાંભળવા માટે આપેલ લીનક સાંભળો –
    હવે તમે જ બતાવો કે હજરત મોહમેદ સ.અ.વ. સુન્ની હતા કે વહાબી કે પછી હનાફી હતા?

  2. Assalamu Aleikom (that means in English Peace be upon you)
    In the Name of God, Most Gracious, Most Merciful
    [Quran 69:43 43 (This is) a Message sent down from the Lord of the Worlds.
    44 And if the apostle were to invent any sayings in Our name,
    45 We should certainly seize him by his right hand,
    46 And We should certainly then cut off the artery of his heart:
    47 Nor could any of you withhold him (from Our wrath). 48 But verily this is a Message for the Allah.fearing.
    In Quran Allah Prohibits the messenger not add anything in the name of Allah and he obeyed this commandment of Allah. While after 200 years all of a sudden four so called Imams emerged and started to collect so called hearsay (પૂર્વજો પાસેથી સાંભળેલી વાતો, கேள்வியறிவு , सुनी हुई बात, سنی سنائ بات, شنید, الإشاعة And developed new science of collecting and writing hearsay(they termed it as HADIS and they labeled them to believe as equal to Quran!!

    These 4 Imam not only fabricated din but divided the Umma into 4 sects.
    Does Buhkari Explain the Quran?
    Link to the article : submission org /#/d/ Does_Hadith_explain_Quran
    140,000 Sahaba (R.A.) was with Hazrat Mohamed (S.A W.) in his last Hajj. There are not a single documentary evidence that anyone dared to write anything.
    If writing Ahadith was true then we are missing 140000 Ahadiths written by these Sahbis(RA).
    4 Calipha of Islam did not ventured to write, teach or tabliq anything but Quran and purely Quran. They could have appointed thousands scholars to write volumes of
    Ahadis as they were the kings. Almost after 7 to 8 generation in order to gain cheap popularity and in the false name of Din (to Please Allah for New Innovation).

    These 4 Imam not only fabricated din but divided the Umma into 4 sects.
    Does Buhkari Explain the Quran?
    Link to the article :

  3. Many of the followers of Tabliqui jamt do not even know what is written in the book Fazaile Ammal, Sadkat Hajj or ay of their publication . It is good business to copy Ahadish from old ahadith book by paying salary to thousands of unemployed maulvis
    Fun of Death definition in Fazaile Amal
    1) What Quran says about death and its time of occurrence
    ( Fazaail-E Aamaaal, ( Eng TRans) Virtues of Charity, chapter 6, page 609 (2nd South African Impression 1414-1993. Published by Warerval Islamic Institute)

    Read how tabliquee makes a jok of Quran and that too inside the mosque in front of Quran and in front of so many Muslims!!

  4. Umer, May Allah give you knowledge of deen... Its unfortunate that you have these misconceptions.

  5. Umer, may Allah save you from misunderstanding Islam...all your comments shown that you really misunderstood our deen...

  6. salam..cuma nak penerangan kenapa rujukan yang dibuat byk tertumpu kepada ulama dri deobandi...wallahualam

  7. This comment has been removed by the author.